Now I've played it, I think Zelda is the winner by far. What do you guys think (people who have played it of course)? I had to hold my vote until I played it!

So far, great story, great GFX, fantastic gameplay and the game is going to last for a pretty long time (70 hours apparently)!

I agree, fantastic game. I am on 9 hrs playtime and just at the entrance to the second dungeon and it's all been great fun, especially the puzzles as the wolf before the second dungeon.

pretty bad bug here though. I hope I remember not to save in that part

ah wait, it's the US version only but still.. I know people from the US read the site so i'll leave it here. Just don't save in that room !

It's very tight between zelda and gow tbh, very tight

I really wasnt that impressed by gow, have pld far far better games just not a prettier one. Not to mention I found a bug where it corrupted my save games and I had to start from the start again.

I only really play GoW in multiplayer as that rocks with some buddies.

Zelda by far, my review should be ready for the new year.

I bought GoW on boxing day, and it is a great game - especially fun in split screen co-op. But as others have stated it's not the revolutionary game people have touted it as at all. It's the best game on the 360 though.

I think the reason why I was impressed with GoW was because I was expecting it to be crap and repetitive. Multiplayer Co-Op surprised me the most though...

Still, Zelda is an over all better game by far. It's also quite rare that a console has a GOTY for a launch title!

well, my vote went to COH, but thats because between the two PC titles it is by far the most fun (five way mp on hamatchi).